The 2006-07 All-Americans were selected at the USIAC tournament in UCLA on 21 May 2006. Due to increased participation at U.S. Indoor nationals, there was an addition of two female compound archers to the team, which then allowed for 10 All-Americans in each division. The compound women had previously been limited to eight. The All-Americans are listed in order of ranking.
| Dakota Sinclair | Saddleback College |
| Jacob Wukie | James Madison University |
| Brett Lazaroff | Atlantic Cape Community College |
| Nathan McCullough | University of Colorado, Colorado Springs |
| Tyler Benner | Claremont-McKenna College |
| Ted Harden | Arizona State University |
| Kevin Barker | Texas A&M University |
| Tim Meyers | Texas A&M University |
| Brian Christensen | Colorado State University |
| Alden Harris | Texas A&M University |
| Lindsey Pian | Arizona State University |
| Lindsey Carmichael | University of Texas |
| Tina Jeon | Yale University |
| Carissa Dragan | California State University, Long Beach |
| Danielle McCullough | Westminster College |
| Robin Liang | Columbia University |
| Marie DeRegnacourt | Michigan State University |
| Sara Mancini | Columbia University |
| Ali Wood | University of Arizona |
| Katrina Weiss | James Madison University |
| Braden Gellenthien | James Madison University |
| Logan Wilde | Idaho State University |
| David Roth | Michigan State University |
| Jedd Greshock | James Madison University |
| Stephen Schwade | James Madison University |
| Joshua Binger | Texas A&M University |
| Michael Ashton | James Madison University |
| Christopher Glass | Michigan State University |
| Trevor Siedel | Texas A&M University |
| Patrick Parsons | Texas A&M University |
| Brittany Lorenti | James Madison University |
| Anna Stratton | Texas A&M University |
| Jessica Grant | Texas A&M University |
| Amanda Raffaelli | Texas A&M University |
| Cassie Raffaelli | Texas A&M University |
| Jessica Fasula | James Madison University |
| Joayn Fleury | James Madison University |
| Michelle Wright | Penn College of Technology |
| Xiao Hui Chin | Columbia University |
| Brenda Temperly | Texas A&M University |